Главная

Sanctions and Russia: Effects, Lessons, and the Future | A History Lab Discussion w/ Stephen Kotkin

Кадры Sanctions and Russia: Effects, Lessons, and the Future | A History Lab Discussion w/ Stephen Kotkin

Описание Sanctions and Russia: Effects, Lessons, and the Future | A History Lab Discussion w/ Stephen Kotkin

Коментарии Sanctions and Russia: Effects, Lessons, and the Future | A History Lab Discussion w/ Stephen Kotkin

Dr Kotkin is indeed an incredible mind in International Affairs, Russian and Asian studies He seems to also understand the economic and business issues Rare indeed He is likely the foremost expert on Stalin as you likely know from even attending this webcast Some of Dr Kotkin's unappreciated talents are a total lack of hubris A man of his stature could easily be pompous Dr Kotkin is not He delivers his presentations in an even manner, with complex issues delivered in simple terms and with a good deal of humour If you look carefully, you will no doubt observe a twinkle in his eye when he addresses certain topics I truly wish that I had had the opportunity to study under Dr Kotkin Instead, I will listen to his lectures and read his books whenever I can Thank you Comment from : @CFPPLANNER

Since the US was the marginal exporter of oil and gas in much of the last decade, greater restrictions and lack of expansion of fracking and pipelines since the election were probably a big part of the rise of oil prices prior to the war The embargo also hurt the West more than a country that chose not to comply with the embargo Comment from : @lazybear236

Sanctions are useless because the country like Iran becoming worst in terrorism Iran kidnap more Americans to bargain and exchange 5 Billion Also Russia weaponized the food and oil Everybody sufferings the aggressions and terrorism Sanctions becoming more tough like Iran, Russia and North Korea Dissolved UN or changed charter to remove Russia as permanent member and must have global Police to enforce violators, terrorism and war aggressors Comment from : @cesaryap8755

speaking of "sanctioning Russia" always reminds me "Continent isolated" meme Comment from : @megaotstoy

Its depressing Pity we can't get Stephen's hot take on Mickey Harte's traitorous move to Tyrone 🤣🇨🇮 Comment from : @patscott8612

What is the effect of the economic friction of “work around” trade deals with third parties for any government but especially for Russia? Comment from : @carylhalfwassen8555

There is no voice on YouTube that I’d rather listen to than Steven kotkin’s Comment from : @Imakulak

I love to listen to a Russian accent once in a while but while Guriev is very articulate, frankly Rasputin's doppelgänger here is hard to follow Did he ever have to teach college students I wonder? Comment from : @dormoisjean-pierre1436

Russia ranked fourth in terms of real GDP growth in the world At the end of the second quarter, the annual figure increased by almost five percent The first three places are in India, China and Indonesia br brThe USA is in ninth place Germany and France did not even make it into the top ten! Comment from : @luckyea7

This is one of the best exposes of the Russian situation Thank you so much Comment from : @juliechristianson8009

The blue collar specialist has bad audio equupment Comment from : @JYRIVIRMA

Lessons? that the West is stupid Comment from : @glenbolderson9279

People seem to be too anxious about being able to predict exactly when the collapse will occur in Russia, but the process of capitulation is similar to when a damn gives way, and I don't think we're going to see a gradual process with clear indicators, and what will likely occur will rather be a sudden, catastrophic implosion with some unpredictable consequences - j q t - Comment from : @quill444

Interesting POV Believe the reason the West went back to Russia after the cold war is Western democracies was hoping Russia would develop a Rule of Law with check and balance system of government That is from government POV It turned out Russians held a grudge all this time Worst yet, Russian is often rule by narcissists which give evolutionary advantage to flying monkeys which ensure more narcissists I say always give anyone country a chance but this time make sure they live up to their promise Putin wanted to join NATO at one point, any nation should have the opportunity to join NATO provided real reforms take place and sustained Comment from : @working_example

2:50 —> please provide actual data and stats to understand the magnitude please Comment from : @SebastianLomaglio

So much expert information So wonderful! And the best accents! Comment from : @jdghgh

Is this Kotkin's podcast? Comment from : @uku4171

god bless you stephen kotkin Comment from : @mattboyle5572

Joe Pesci is a great scholar and Russia expert! Comment from : @lucay2222

I see Stephen kotkin i listen! Comment from : @MasayaShida

Kotkin is pee wee Herman in the flesh So nasal and arrogant Comment from : @dimsum947

We should not be at war with Russia Nut job Russophobes running incompetent American policy Comment from : @NineInchTyrone

The sanctions guy is giving good info, but I can barely understand him Do they have a transcript? Comment from : @jackstratif6937

I found this so funny, the salt is so real The sanctions haven't worked, and they don't like it The war is like COVID people like on this video can't sick to facts and just push agendasbrIt was admitted at the 57 min markbrIn the past I would have listened and assumed what they are saying as facts wow coming from the Hoover Institution, but COVID and the Ukraine war I show me that the public needs to listen to both sides Comment from : @Peter-ll7vq

BS podcast Comment from : @MrMSalexanderMK

👍🍺 Comment from : @halmoore8558

I lost a lot of respect for Stephen Kotkin when he started promoting the idea that Ukraine should make territorial concessions to Russia to 'win the peace' Comment from : @ah5555

58:44 look right through Comment from : @Youlovesky_Max

I read volume I and volume II of Stalin by Kotkin I've no interest in Volume III anymore Kotkin, as a historian, spent his entire life learning and teaching about Russia Now I see he does not understand a dime about Russia That's pity Comment from : @johnbidon9573

Someone here is censoring the FACT I want to make, that Stephen Kotkin completely fell for the Trump Russian Collusion Hoax for literally years, and it has severely damaged a lot of his credibility as an analyst on contemporary Russian-related issues Sorry to hurt your feelings, but it's true! Search 2017-2019 Kotkin comments and see how he was duped for yourselves! Other than that, this is a fine discussion But the Kotkin sycophancy here has gotta stop! He's NOT infallible! lol Comment from : @junkscience6397

People always talk what they want to hear Comment from : @serseniucst

Who knew Joe Pesci was so knowledgeable on Russia! Academy awards, Russian history, what can't he do! 😂 Comment from : @michaelnewman1813

Three stooges… Comment from : @shahanshah2223

I came to listen to Kotkin, not two long-winded academics with thick accents! Comment from : @telluwide5553

The west has run out of Ukrainians, what’s plan B? Comment from : @thomasdonovan3580

35 in a jump is crazy Comment from : @Ynotnow9900

Is that the sound system or does kotkin just has a female voice? Comment from : @willliam1420

One word - Kotkinization in Condoleezztitution Seems that Lab is the place of sinecurization That is already 3 words- too much Comment from : @vladimirdosen9767

All countries fiddle economic data including the ones the speakers come from Comment from : @ahmedkiyimba5934

35:24 can someone explain the issue on the blunder of trading bilateral currency please? brWhy is the trade balance condition important? Thank you Comment from : @ferdinandimposter691

I adore listening to Sergi Guriev - I have heard his analyses on several other online venues Besides being smart, I find him very charming! I had not seen Michael S Bernsam before but really appreciated his detailed discussion of the Russian economic situation As for you, Stephen, I have sat through many of your online lectures and this was just another great performance Thank you all for helping us understand this very complex situation!! Comment from : @russell3060

Bernsthom russian exile and former advisor of the Yeltsin government on economics, the same Yeltsin government that raped the Russian economy greatly aided by western advisorsbrGuriev, head of the Russian anti war coalition whose stated charter aim is to fight against the authoritarian rule of PutinbrbrSorry it was an interesting watch, but Kotkins assertion at the start that this is an attempt to just have a factual look at the topic without any sides or agendas or what they'd like to happen is absolutely laughablebrbrKotkin has a great mind, but the host of a self stated neutral study of this topic he is not Comment from : @stephendyer5879

A very interesting discussion, gentlemen! 😃 Comment from : @niravelniflheim1858

Excellent discussion Enlightening and clarifying Illuminated some important new aspects of the shell game of wartime Russian economy Thanks for the depth and insight of the questions, and also for the smart answers I feel happily edified! 😊 Comment from : @mnoot7209

This is excellent I recommend it Why wasn't transcript turned on? The ccs were helpful but transcript helps me find the sentence I need repeated because of the dense content and Bernstam's accent Comment from : @jeanneknight4791

I see Kotkin, I like Comment from : @arktseytlin

In the west world governments and private entities are the same, currently the coorporations are the owners and masters of the western governments supposedly democrats but really imposed by a capitalist plutocracy The sanctions have the only goal to destroy the Russian Federation because interpones between them and their capitalist interests Comment from : @eduardopacheco9715

It has been suggested that some of the oil wells need to keep producing to avoid damage Could this be involved? Comment from : @donhansen1175

Russia 🇷🇺 is doing great They are on a mission for God, because of the N@zi ideology our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ wants 🛑 STOPPED ✝️✡️🕎☦️❤️ Comment from : @joecartwright9221

Do you follow Hoover? Good for you Comment from : @evasvitek15

This has been great bonus for india & others while the west dont want to develop their energy & manufacturing Comment from : @paulbadics3500

"Why would anyone be so stupid to forgo revenue?" i guess he doesnt know trudeau in Canada has purposely stifled oil & gas export pipelines losing tens of billions of $ & hurting the canadian people Comment from : @paulbadics3500

Russia is supplying the rest of the world with oil, gas, agriculture, minerals, fertilizer while the west is doing everything possible destroy their energy & manufacturing & mining economies Comment from : @paulbadics3500

Sanctions or not Russia is able to out produce US & UK Europe in artillery which is what counts Comment from : @paulbadics3500

You would think this was a discussion from spring of 22we know now most of these sanctions have back fired Comment from : @paulbadics3500

Sanctions have been far worse for EU UK especially & even USlook at mass inflation, energy shortages etc Comment from : @paulbadics3500

They were all 100 wrong about sanctions like they were about covidrussia has expanded its trade & export import opportunities, building bric alliance, growing its manufacturing Comment from : @paulbadics3500

Finally a realistic overview of the sanctions and how they are impacting the Russian economy instead of the amateur journalists predicting the collapse of the Russian economy every two days Comment from : @stefansekulic7903

A very illuminating discussion; thank you to the host and guests And, your new eyeglasses are very stylish, Professor Kotkin :) Comment from : @alancats

a this guys on drugs??? Comment from : @arnoldtoralba1817

One of the best interviews ever about the effects of sanctions on russian economy 👏👏👏👏👏👏 Comment from : @bostjankavcic7793

‘How situation is not how we want it to be’? So, US couldn’t calculate the consequences of their actions? what’s new Comment from : @Soboris

Tea is better for the Russian exceptional brain than Vodka!brIt is moreover the best developmental aid, as the Russian expensive refinieries rot and those in India and Bangladesh bloombrNo wonder that India managed it to the dark side of the moon and Russia did not Drink tea! Comment from : @mushtaqbhat1895

Colonel Sanders knows best Comment from : @edgarivanarmentamtz5793

⭐ Comment from : @robertprawendowski2850

I can't understand the colonel Comment from : @classactionsteve

I would have received more value from this conversation if there had been a third more "Russian positive" economist to counter the view points brAlso, what about the Russian sanctions unintended effects on Western Europe, which by all reports is that they're in recession And, without Russian gas Germany might permanently lose is industrial base What's Europe's cost for Russian sanctions? Comment from : @michaelb6529

There is explicit sanctions and implicit sanctions , Comment from : @sparkyfromel

These guys could not get a job at McDonald's Comment from : @gavinstutler3229

Useless Comment from : @asayeworku363

The policy should be: 1) take one proven case of importing something big or important (eg airplane parts) 2) announce sanctions against (a) country which let it happen, or (b) bank which performed the payments, or (c) the company that arranged it allbrPutting up sanctions against entire countries may be too severe, and governments there may be unable to control actions of unscrupulous importers Case (c) is also not effective, as such transactions are likely done via ghost companies just created for this purpose a week prior and disbanded after But case (b) — punishing unscrupulous banks — is very doable and effective Setting up “ ghost banks” is not easy, so real, established banks are used Banks know what such transactions are for ( totals are in millions of dollars ), and the mechanism is simple and reliable — cut them off from SWIFT, or impose penalties on their transactions brAnd yes — Swiss banks — get ready Aiding Russia has to stop! Comment from : @nickmon6497

Is it just me or does Stephen Kotkin sound incredibly like Joe Pesci? Comment from : @whyem516H

) Comment from : @jbqu3142

We don't know when this discussion was filmed, but it's too bad it was done just before Prigozhin was blown out of the sky I'm looking forward to hearing what Stephen has to say about this Comment from : @sbaumgartner9848

Amazing discussing, among which was the insight that Russia massively cut off its nose to spite its face when it insisted on the payment of its oil exports in rupees and renminbi, rather than dollars (Note: I'm pretty sure Russia originally insisted on payment from India and China in rubles, but settled on payment in the currencies of each of those respective countries) Comment from : @guydreamr

If you had bigger cohones you should begin every interview with a Russian with the question “ should Crimea revert to being Ukrainian territory?” Their answer will tell us a lot about how to interpret what they say Comment from : @andyjay5903

It is a mistake to use classical US economic theory as the measure This is War against the global structure that was established post WW2 Putin does not give a damn about economic theory He sees the world being run by Czars with absolute power, and he trying to induce a global collapse of the post WW2 order on a scale greater than 1929 He also sees the Russian federation surviving such a collapse due to its built in strengths of natural resources, and captive population that is used to hardshipbrbrHaving China and India purchasing Russian oil is actually a good thing It removes market pressure from the Middle east suppliers And that is stabilising the global order Comment from : @user-sq5bw2fc4n

Thanks for this interesting and competent talk Comment from : @anjafark

Should should hollow out the Russian army and industry by opening the border to young men and women of college age Comment from : @user-sq5bw2fc4n

Idiots, don't listen to those who are paid to lie Comment from : @voldemarsorochinskiy77

I'm amused by the political analysis of these two Russians They either lost the 'russinness' of their souls or simply are not honest with the audience Anyone who repeats the mantra of 'lack of ammunition' or 'no support for Putin in Russia' is either lying to themselves or to others Comment from : @potapotapova9375

🧐 The infrastructure project "The bee honeycomb model of the conglomerates" will keep your money 🐝💰 The Project is more Reliable than Gold 🪙 Comment from : @archimedesxxicentury

Sanctions shoud be used to cut our relatiions with Russia esp culture and sports Comment from : @natbirchall1580

Simply put: an excellent discussion Covers most of the important economic topics that are rarely, if ever, addressed in the media If you have a question about Russian economic policy there is a good chance you will find your answer in this video Comment from : @lawjef

A superb discussions regarding the Russian economy since their invasion of Ukraine Each person has exceptional economic knowledge and insight Absolutely riveting Everyone should listen Thanks to the esteemed guests and to Stephen Kotkin for putting this together Comment from : @chozumi

Michael Guriev it's good expert We can trust him Comment from : @ctenvao

Biden forgot to say "birthgiving person of all sanctions" so sanctions got offended and they refuse to work 😂 Comment from : @edibbesirevic6356

When u can't see ur enemy winning Pray a blindside doesn't catch ur backside Comment from : @steveagola9317

Thank you gentlemen, hope some Russian people listened and spread the knowledge It’ll only help to diminish the damage their president is imposing on their state Comment from : @silviadunderdale9400

Похожие на Sanctions and Russia: Effects, Lessons, and the Future | A History Lab Discussion w/ Stephen Kotkin видео

Russia-Ukraine war and sanctions spur increasing calls for crypto regulation: CNBC Crypto World РѕС‚ : CNBC Television Download Full Episodes | The Most Watched videos of all time

Can Russia use cryptocurrency to dodge sanctions? | DW Business Special РѕС‚ : DW News Download Full Episodes | The Most Watched videos of all time

EU sanctions on Russia explained РѕС‚ : European Parliamentary Research Service Download Full Episodes | The Most Watched videos of all time

Bao giờ có thể rút được kin về ví- achi kiếm tiền online РѕС‚ : Achi kiếm tiền online Download Full Episodes | The Most Watched videos of all time

Pingu Intro 1986 Effects (Sponsored by 30th Century Logo Effects) РѕС‚ : BEST LOGO EFFECTS EVER! Download Full Episodes | The Most Watched videos of all time

Sentence starters for Group Discussion | Group Discussion Tips | TalentSprint РѕС‚ : TalentSprint Coding Prep Download Full Episodes | The Most Watched videos of all time

Lessons Emerging from the JEDI Cloud: Immediate Steps and the Future of Next-Generation IT РѕС‚ : Hudson Institute Download Full Episodes | The Most Watched videos of all time

Hostel tour of medical college Russia | MBBS in Russia | Tver State Medical University РѕС‚ : Vivek Lathwal Download Full Episodes | The Most Watched videos of all time

Panel Discussion - ICOs and The Future of Blockchain Startup Funding РѕС‚ : Token Fest Download Full Episodes | The Most Watched videos of all time

Bitcoin sinks to $26,000, and OFAC sanctions crypto wallets tied to North Korea: CNBC Crypto World РѕС‚ : CNBC Television Download Full Episodes | The Most Watched videos of all time