Starship vs N1... Is Starship doomed to repeat history?

Video quality	The size	Download

Информация о Starship vs N1... Is Starship doomed to repeat history?

Название	:	Starship vs N1... Is Starship doomed to repeat history?
Продолжительность	:	30.15
Дата публикации	:
Просмотров	:	1,1 jt

SpaceX has better technology than Russia
Comment from : ohjdcv

The Chinese will be the first on the moon
Comment from : Космонавтика Видео

Starship will face the same problem that BMW have Over engineered
Comment from : SoppyBottomBoys

best advocate for knowing if SpaceX is f… up, is Nasa: even after the 2nd test? they went back to Blue Origin for the Mars mission
Comment from : LPchannel

i think Starship will work 100 at the 4th flight It will need 2 Years and target will be reached 2025
Comment from : netlink196803161903

There's nothing to repeat N1 has only couple tests
Comment from : Алексей Балабаев

how many explosions star ship has to go through before it's finally manage to barely exceed N1 achivement
Comment from : Planet Walking

No
Comment from : simon ethier

Looking back from the future after the second launch of starship you have nothing to worry about Tim
Comment from : Cory Crandell

Hope thing's eventually work for your sake, Tim!
Comment from : Greg Sayles

24:35brElon's contributive value vs the lead engineer during an era of the cold war and no internet is not even an ounce of comparable
Comment from : Kimeters

Musk accomplished the impossible and, of course, wrote his name on the tablets of history Two tests of Starship showed its excellent performance After final development, he will single-handedly occupy Olympus of the main space transport The H1 did not take off due to lack of technology, necessary funding and the death of Korolev But the main reason for the failure was the “skillful” leadership of the big bosses from the Politburo, who only know how to compost brains and puff out their cheeks
Comment from : Сергей М

As long as Government doesn't limit him - but sadly looks a though they're attempting
Comment from : Bigred130

MONEY ISNT REAL I WISH THAT WE AS HUMANS WERE FINALLY ABLE TO FULLY REALIZE THIS AND IN THIS WAY STARSHIP CAN NEVER FAIL UNLESS A 30 KM ASTEROID HITS THE EARTH BEFORE WE'RE ABLE TO COLONIZE (COLONISERS) SPACE, WE CANT EVER FAIL AT ANYTHING UNLESS WE CHOOSE TO
Comment from : ThothHeartMaat

Why not do a Kerbal and just chain a bunch of falcon 9s together, its already a pretty successful rocket, i mean isnt that what the falcon heavy basically was?
Comment from : JTheory

Great video Lot's of good information Just one pet peave - please stop using the word "utilize" when the word "use" does the job
Comment from : Dan Waters

So I rewatched this and Holy mackerel so starship already beaten the n1 rocket LETSGOOO
Comment from : Unrelated Guy

When is the next starship launch? And what is the expected future starship launch schedule?
Comment from : Jayden Lawson

They also said he couldn't land boosters and yet here we are with spacex landing boosters after they detach
Comment from : Gutenburg100

As always another great video Tim, thanks for the education
Comment from : Kris Crichton

Just a day ago I saw a Russian meme about similarity of Korolev and Musk and N-1 with the Starship It was called "The second coming"
Comment from : Павел и Порох

It took 7 months
Comment from : Benedek Fodor

This metal bird is only for reaching the Moon Too many engines is a big mistake Humans will go to Mars but not on a Starship The new engine will be invented around 2040 using AI and a super quantum computer Q1 I haven't said anything upps
Comment from : Alex Horvath

Great video! Thank you so much for terrific insights into these space ships including the sides by side comparisons of both ships I watched the N1s launch and they were impressive Now Starship has topped that with this second flight Even though both components were destroyed prior to completing their mission, they performed several tasks that will give SpaceX a lot of new data I was sad that neither stage was able to complete their total mission through the landing of either the booster or landing the Starship itself They will do it next time! Go SpaceX! ❤ Go Elon!❤ It is about time we finally got off of the Earth and back into Space with our own ships
Comment from : Janet Sorenson

Starship has already exceeded the best N1 flight
Comment from : Joseph Astier

почему не пошли по пути ракеты Сатурн?brона была безотказной
Comment from : Анатольевич

Well, that one didn’t age so well
Comment from : Cardboard

Yes, dont forget about gimballing, and hydro vs EVC This past launch just shows ya that the next one will complete their mission brSSG Will
Comment from : NOM

The usual pattern on how you should treat deadlines with a question mark in them, nobrbrIt was just too early for N1 IFT-2 has proven without a doubt now that having many engines is good
Comment from : Avaruusmurkku

Suck eggs he already won
Comment from : Robert Bolding

Watched it last week fly and it was beautiful you need to do more work on these videos
Comment from : Flush The toilet(SyD6_7)

Sure, the Starship will be able to launch 300 tons to orbit, but unlike the N1 or Saturn V it won't be able to leave Earth orbit
Comment from : pahtar

Seems yes so alot raptors machine Doesn't look good probability to every machine
Comment from : Outer space

after IFT2, Starship is definitely going to succeed
Comment from : Ten minutes of Minecraft

I think that there are many people wrong about the fact that if they go to space they automatically become astronauts, that is like saying that if you buy a plane ticket you automatically become a pilot or an aeronautical engineer, that is stupid, the reality is that going to space only qualifies you to be cargo, you will be a spaceship passenger or a space tourist and that's it not to mention that if you go to Mars you will only be an immigrant, never ever an astronaut
Comment from : Anibal Lecter

This video didn't hold up well lol
Comment from : Livinghighandwise

weight in milli tons? why pls? 4:00
Comment from : magic

It might be too big to be reusable
Comment from : mkvenner2

Well after IFT2 things turned out great❤🎉🎉🎉
Comment from : rutendo chikwanha

When do space x engines expire? Do they count how many launches or total flight minutes or hours?
Comment from : Ken Street

It is just Koro-lev, not Korel - liev
Comment from : Steven Mann

Bite the big one 🚀
Comment from : James Palazzi

Get a real job
Comment from : Dan Wright

CGI Show
Comment from : Lord Gondor

Ask me again when it reaches LEO
Comment from : pjqziggy oid

I think the rapter engine will improve in the years to come just look at the differences between test one flight and test flight 2 I think a fully successful test flight will be at test flight 5 that's my prediction 😀 🤔
Comment from : Colin Dobson

An unresolved issue for Starship appears to be the heat shield tile adhesion failures It will be interesting to see how this is addressed and hopefully resolved
Comment from : Brad Karthauser

28:25 Hearing this question after just having watched the second flight test sent the chills through my spine!
Comment from : Igor Simon

Yes
Comment from : Julian Morrisco

Unfortunately Starship will suffer faliures of BOTH N1 and Saturn
Comment from : Михаил Розов

Curious effect of the clouds at 9:10
Comment from : Alex

Starship officially beat the N1 !
Comment from : ADAMSMASHRR

It flew with all 33 raptor engines with grace in the second try
Comment from : Richard

Just wanted to say::brbthere are a lot of amateur, and even some professional channels that cover space, rocketry, etc Yet, this channel and Tim Dodd have the best content!/bbrbrWhat a great time to be alive! 🦾br😎🇺🇸
Comment from : D Cypher

13:57 That's why I don't eat meat from Texas
Comment from : w23857980

Too many points of failure
Comment from : Fernando Hood

13:40brYou mention or muse that “… perhaps those Raptor engines weren’t so reliable after all” The accompanying video shows what we all saw at the 4/20 launch that some of the engines appeared not to be functioningbrbrRather than pointing to unreliability issues would you consider that those engines were damaged by debris torn up from concrete structures at the base of the pad that we saw flying about and even damaging nearby fuel tanks?
Comment from : I B Newton

The NK-15 is so simple looking compared to the Raptor 2
Comment from : Uncommon Sense

"being fully reusable", "being the most capable rocket" - normally you'd wait for a rocket actually working/doing service before making statements like that
Comment from : Brain Decay

A good bit of personal perspective is that Starship is the same height as Lex Luther’s Drop of Doom in six flag magic mountain both standing at 120m
Comment from : Luke Cunningham

Most powerful rocket champs again!!!! 🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
Comment from : Luke Cunningham

I think Starship will eventually accomplish the mission but I don't think it will be on the current schedule NASA has set with a Rendezvous of Next year orbiting the moon with Artemis 2 and a landing of 2025 That is an aggressive schedule with a rocket that is very experimental Unless SpaceX can Step it up
Comment from : Robert Benoit

I am reliable engine, my neighbours failure doesnt affect me
Comment from : Jukka Muhonen

Great work pushing your narrative
Comment from : DineshKumar पुत्र

28:25 yessir, everything you mentioned happened Not in a year, in few months
Comment from : Avi

خیلی خیلی ممنون از این همه زحمتی که برای این ویدئو کشیدی
Comment from : mahmud rostamlu

Das sich da überhaupt mal einer auf die Spitze einer kleinen Atombombe setzt (wenn die Rakete 🚀 fehlschlägt), ist schon bemerkenswert, finde ichbrIch hoffe, dann hat jemand einen 🧯 parat!
Comment from : Prickel Pit

I guess the IFT2 triggered the algo for this to show up now No need to comment about what happened to answer the questions at the end of the video I believe IFT3 will reach orbit Love what SpaceX is doing and NOT being bloated on NASA contracts for vessels that are thrown away
Comment from : T B

28:25, YEAP!! I seen it yesterday! LOL ❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥
Comment from : Justin Mead

Make the nessasary adjustments and send it up one more time! We need that Data!!!
Comment from : Templar Tone

Well at least SpaceX finally got a flame diverter and a hot staging algorithm like the Soviet N1 So eventually 21st century engineering will catch with problems identified in the 20th century
Comment from : Dan P

If N1's project continues to this day The starship doesn't even exist
Comment from : Chat GoPT

26:20 You were saying? 😂😂😂
Comment from : A55hol3 Actual

good summary
Comment from : Peet Ky

Well, this is awkward
Comment from : cprhroaehssneteonr

If the N1 had raptors it would be a different story
Comment from : BB

starship far more successful than N1 even the first launch
Comment from : Jamesun Z

14:00 are those cows already got used to the booster engine blasting near by? lol
Comment from : K Chiu

no because murica
Comment from : LightsCameraJake

State run
Comment from : Ryu Shogun

So, here we are now Must feel pretty good to get your opinions not only validated but even surpassed in the very next flight of starship!
Comment from : Dennis Klomp

Who’s here after starship launched and had all 33 engines fire the entire burn??
Comment from : Ryan Hamstra

Turns out the Starship has already made it through stage separation successfully
Comment from : Steven Reed

After today"s flight I would say no problem
Comment from : Robert Campbell

Having just witnessed the 2nd IFT this morning its safe to say that starship will not suffer the same fate and the N1
Comment from : fakiirification

THANK YOU FOR METRIC MEASUREMENTS
Comment from : Станислав Лем

"It can put 300 metric tons into orbit" That remains to be seenbrbrEveryday simp for Elmo has long seemed like a better name
Comment from : Ed Walker

no it will not after today WOOOoo
Comment from : IraqLobsterr

yep many engines many riskskeep it simple
Comment from : Simon Nomis

it was enough to hear that false information about the largest rocket was N1, closed
Comment from : Aboba

Can’t wait for the Block 5 Starships You know they’re coming I picture that being in 2025-26 brSpaceX is online to rule commercial space in a short time
Comment from : Tim York

Elon has drive, he has knowledge, and of coarse he has money and hires the best he can find How to fail is just a way to answer how to succeed for him I still have questions, but am more optimistic than doubtful
Comment from : Donaldscheid