Is QNAP Security Any Good?

Video quality	The size	Download

Информация о Is QNAP Security Any Good?

Название	:	Is QNAP Security Any Good?
Продолжительность	:	6.27
Дата публикации	:
Просмотров	:	31 rb

You are spot-on about QNAP software And it's pretty easy to see Just press F12 after you have logged in and look at the console tab in the Chrome debugger That area should be empty if you are writing good software But what you will actually see is code that is in beta It has comments it has chrome warnings about using outdated techniques And most importantly it has errors Their software is a joke DO NOT expose a QNAP NAS to the internet
Comment from : @LokiDaFerret

It’s not a backup if it needs special hardware to retrieve data And is always online and powered😂😢
Comment from : @scottblackburn2969

Ransomware virus (qqjj) has destroyed a lot of my photos and videos Can the destroyed photos and videos be restored?
Comment from : @roshanrukantha4284

Months later, time for a review video! ADRA NDR is in place What do you think?
Comment from : @adamg8588

Thanks for your video I almost bought a QNAP instead of a Synology just because they had 25 Gbe NIC at the consumer level
Comment from : @tofu_golem

Do you know of another product that allows you to get around port forwarding blocks from isps Ive been looking amd only wd has one but it has no local access
Comment from : @tmastersat

QNAP and Synology are based in Taiwan Taiwan was established and remained a dictatorship for many decades It's in the mindset to force updates
Comment from : @jnagarya519

What NAS out there has never and I mean never had a security breach? Let me know so I can buy it now Really bad actors can circumvent a VLAN; I guess there's no such thing as a hopping attack
Comment from : @DJaquithFL

thank you, i still have the 7z randsomware and now the deadlock, no sign from qnap thinking to go online
Comment from : @alsoknownas3004

The most recent QTS firmware didn't provide a supported ClamAV version - ClamAV 0102, 0101 End of Life is Jan 3, 2022 Once again no proper obsolence management
Comment from : @bluesangel75

I total agree they should not do a force update and reboot "end off"
Comment from : @philsbbs

I just need a really good DAS setup, you have any suggestions for that? Purchase or software for a DIY setup?
Comment from : @mdh3421

Does this mean I should trash my QNAP? What’s a better option out there for a more secure NAS
Comment from : @JHJOwen

Security is one of the reason, I kept my QNAP behind Pfsense firewall and VPN configured on it Prior to that I used get lot of unknown login attempts on my NAS as DNS was exposing the public IP
Comment from : @GianeshwarJamwal

How about the security of QNAP 10GbE desktop managed switches? I was considering buying a QSW-M1208-8C instead of a NETGEAR ProSafe XS716T - since NETGEAR also have a poor reputation for firmware updates frequency / security and they only recently released a security firmware update for the XS716T switch after TWO YEARS (2019-2021) - at least the QSW-M1208-8C seems to have gotten updated every 3 months or so since early 2021 going by their website change-logbrbrQNAP's managed switch GUI looks more modern / user friendly than NETGEAR and their most recent switch update states they've added digital signing to firmware and prevent downgrading to an earlier versionbrbrSo whilst QNAP NAS devices might not be recommended from a security standpoint, does the same opinion also apply to their managed switches?
Comment from : @mashiroshiina3453

Yeah, I got hit by their forced update in one of my QNAPs Even though I have yet to be harmed, I’m not happy about that and will block off their ability to talk to the internet brbrI regret my decision to buy QNAP and feel I should have built purpose built PCs for the same tasks
Comment from : @asdf51501

[LAUGHS IN DELL POWEREDGE]
Comment from : @matte2160

I have 2 Qnap's and love them Neither one has had any "forced updates" in the 4 years I've owned them You should read better reliable sources
Comment from : @waynespringer501

Couldn't agree more Yes, Synology has issues too, but they at least attempt to keep their platform up to date from a security perspective
Comment from : @spyrule

Synology has had their share of ransomware, and they were in the news about this, even in 2021 QNAP really has to improve on how they handle security, that I totally agree with
Comment from : @PeterDHoye

It's a pity because they have way more hardware configuration options than Synology, but I have always found the Synology OS more polished Have been on Synology for many years and have always found them very robust and reliable - the  of the NAS world ;)
Comment from : @deonh9303

Just to answer your Question No
Comment from : @blyatspinat

Supposedly, there is several software OS including open source ones that you can run on your Qnap to replace theirs especially if it is beyond security updates but it will have those “shoehorn” issues of not being specifically customized for the hardware and will require you to deal with a greater level of administration issues Not worth it if you are looking for a brand new system
Comment from : @saywhat9158

Why people have nas devices directly connected to the internet always puzzles me
Comment from : @rs6w

What is your recomendation instead for a two drive system for smb file sharing and nfs support instead of the qnap?
Comment from : @DanielHaanpaa

I’ve got a QNAP but only use it due to got a fantastic deal via a mate that couldn’t work it I would personally use a Synology if I had to purchase 1 new Hardware not brill but the software makes up for it Shame QNAP are doing this to there own product as they could be a serious contender with Synology if they actually sorted the clunky UI
Comment from : @ChrisBarrow1990

I seems like this attack has not been proven out how it was done It's interesting as the number of units attacked is small compared to the base of Qnap users? Having a Qnap TVS-H1288X I have been trying to get as much info as possible I believe Im locked down well So far so good I love the machine
Comment from : @kimlynch5526

I have my QNAP updates off, and was very surprised when my system unexpectedly rebooted Examining the logs revealed that the reboot was triggered by an update
Comment from : @MalachiTheBowlingGod

Lol its like the Boeing Max
Comment from : @Crazy--Clown

So this post is just saying "Don't buy QNAP, because they're insecure" Sounds pretty simple to me Got it! Thanks Lawrence
Comment from : @BrianThomas

I don't open my Pfsense for anything not even VPN Still after that last ransomware attack a few months ago I put in rules to block all outgoing traffic on both of my QNAP devices The company only cares about releasing new hardware and could care less about security I only need a NAS for local access anyway That company is a joke
Comment from : @notta3d

What about a Qnap system running Unraid as the OS? Would that be a little bit more secure rather than running the Qnap OS?
Comment from : @libertycornwell3144

First
Comment from : @TechySpeaking

Is there a new vulnerability on top of the ransomware from 2021?
Comment from : @TumescentPuma

“A company that DOES NOT want to fix the issues”brbrThat is a lie and you are just another exaggerated and unfair personbrbrYou people like all the features and it’s hard to keep such idiotic setups safe!brbrMy 2 QNAP systems (not production, just to know them) have been 100 perfect, for the last 5 years,, because I understand security
Comment from : @pepeshopping

This is not the first time for QNAP If they can force an update, so can a threat actor They are dead to me
Comment from : @keyboard_g

Their hardware definitely looks appealing however too many issues with security so won't even consider
Comment from : @kc0eks

Tom what do you use? I use qnap due to the phone app I can install on all phones and sync photos automatically Is there other solutions? For like unraid or truenas?
Comment from : @babbjos

I have a QNAP that I have overall been very happy with overall, however I saw tons of login attempts as admin (which I disabled during the initial configuration) and removed the cloud component of it as a result of that I have remote access VPN so if need to get to it when I am away from home I can, but it shouldn't be reachable without breaching my environment in some other kind of way first It does suck that the cloud component of that isn't really usable thoughbrbrThat said as a company their security posture is absolutely unacceptable
Comment from : @Gearbhall

Run! Run Away!
Comment from : @SomeGuyInSandy

I have a QNAP NAS for my backup, I manually turn it on Backup, turn it off ;-)
Comment from : @MrHeHim

Have had security problems with QNAP some years ago Caused a lot of problems for me personally Never any QNAP for me again
Comment from : @HermanIdzerda

I have not much running on my qnap but it's always trying to connect to a Domain in the netherlands Pfblocker blocks it but no one Knows what this is
Comment from : @skorpion1298

I have owned several QNAP units or the past 20 years They make a solidly built unit ( I only ever bought SMB models) I never opened up any part of them to the internet, so I never had a issue Their boot and shutdown times are painfully slow My supermicro MB boot faster and they are server boards QTS and there apps have been awful for the last 10 years and only get worse Full firmware update cycle - reboot, update firmware and reboot can take 45 mins which is crazy I have owned two ASUSTOR units and they are way better all around Less than 2 mins from off to fully running and web accessable, QNAP about 8 mins Great HW, buggy OS and apps I revamped one of the QNAPs to run TrueNAS and it is working very well So sad they have such a lousy track record for be ing so buggy and such
Comment from : @andymok7945

QNAP is pretty attractive from a hardware standpoint, but the software has always been a dumpster fire Now, if we could just get Synology to use hardware that's only 3-5 years old like QNAP does instead of using the thing that controlled the airlock in the original Trojan horse as a CPU
Comment from : @black7germany

QNAP is no Good It does not provide good support or product security Buyer Beware
Comment from : @pedroandresriveralopez9148

Glad i just finished moving over the Synology from Qnap Always had issues and did a firmware update and screwed over my raid 5 20TB i couldnt reclaim unless i wiped it all! Bought the Synology that you did a video on and couldn't be happier!!!
Comment from : @MrLocoAndrew

Who do you recommend? Do you have setup videos of running some you recommend that need to be accessible over the internet?
Comment from : @CraigMullins1

Thanks for this! Now I really 100 sure I will never buy QNAP
Comment from : @valin0r

For years had issues with qnap, all the time security updates, nearly never could run the nas for a week without restart because of updates
Comment from : @ig23174

Security focused IT people would have a lot less to do if people could stop just open things up to the www nothing to do, but less
Comment from : @dariantel