HPS Vs CMH Vs LED | Should you upgrade from HPS and MH?

Video quality	The size	Download

Информация о HPS Vs CMH Vs LED | Should you upgrade from HPS and MH?

Название	:	HPS Vs CMH Vs LED \| Should you upgrade from HPS and MH?
Продолжительность	:	15.38
Дата публикации	:
Просмотров	:	198 rb

LED wins every time
Comment from : dtjrealmc

Would like to see an updated version of this
Comment from : Steve P

You look so stoned
Comment from : Satish Sehdev

Pro tip…don’t change to Hps until week 3 of flower This reduces the “stretch “ big time
Comment from : Paul

Isn't the only heat savings with led when you use less watt IE replace a 600hps with a 400w led because a watt always gives off the same btu?
Comment from : C L

LED ok for Veg Metal Halide Best for VegbrHPS Best for flowering and yield size That is all you need to know
Comment from : Backup in the Day

Update: After 2 years with top of the line LEDS (LUMATEK 600w pro) and regular double ended CMHs (Solux 630w LEC) I can state the following;brbr1 LEDS are great for indoor growing during the summerbr2 The yield is about the same with both lights without C02br3 LEDS with C02 do produce about 15 more than CMH with C02 br4 Larger nugs with CMH and harder nugs with LEDS Too hard for my liking br5 For newbies or growers with low ceilings I would recommend CMH, its easier to manage light distance, burnt leaves are a real issue with powerfull ledsbr6 The low far RED in LED means I need to give the clones 3-5 days of veg compared to the 0-1 days of CMH br7 I use about 20 higher EC values with LEDs brbrSame tent size, (4x4) (1,20x,120) same clones, and pretty much the same conditionsbrbrGrower since 1997
Comment from : Salo Vila

Hi migro one question what meter do i get for hps and which one should i buy for led is there a difference between those light meters?
Comment from : Smoked Out Tutorials

Are you reading something you've researched? Have you had hands on experience with what you're presenting here? Because you don't sound very convincing
Comment from : TurboSteve

No double-ended HPS?
Comment from : Randy Logan

Obviously you've never grown with any of these
Comment from : Sean Johnson

Hello, i bought me from Lumatek the cmh 315 W thta whats in your vid, did i need for bloom and for veg an extra bulb, because i saw there are two version, i think philips was the brand that offert them
Comment from : Roger Smith

Thank you, I am from Argentina, Capital Federal and here I only find the ceramic HPS light of 315 watts from the SINOWELL brandbrI wanted to know if it is good and which one should I buy the 3000k or 4000k
Comment from : Jorge Jara Ramos

show the front and led temp nect time, much more informative You can turn the lights off in case the heat image doesnt work with LEDs on I bet the front of that QB288 was over 60c
Comment from : Peer Rücke

The lumatek cmh 630 would beat all these lights
Comment from : Billy Ballsup

Would two single ended hps light a 4x4 area well ? I know it's not the best option
Comment from : J H

Have u guys/anyone looked into xenon energy saving discharge (XED )?
Comment from : Daniel Verwey

125 video speed Thank me later
Comment from : Slobodan Radović

Can Robert invent a device that can help the Russians and any of its supporters see the light that putin is hitlers idal now that would be worth making a fuss about 😏
Comment from : Jamie Toyne

you should do a video on the differences between the phillips 3100k, 4200k, and Agro Spectrum
Comment from : Kyle Smiley

Ceramic HPS or ceramic MH in the end?
Comment from : Practical Drum Concepts with Heather Higley

Curious why didn't you involve lecs
Comment from : makaveli the exotic micro bully

I'm pretty sure 600 watts of HPS will grow more than 241 watts of LED I've used both Also, excess heat should be evaluated in any comparison Led will always win thermal radiation In the south, HID requires air conditioning which is not cheap
Comment from : Angelina 32310

iv been upgrading from HPS to LED in my smaller areas and tents i have replaced 3 600 watt air cooled with LED so far but my 5x5 flowering tent using 1000 watt HPS is the challenge to replace with LED the energy savings in light watt draw in the 5x5 is minimal but i will save a lot of power draw because i will not require the 4 ton a/c unit to run wide open to cool the grow room the 2 five by five flowering tents are in so far i have replACED 400 AND 600 WATT AIR COOLED HOOD HPS WITH MARS HYDRO SP300 X2 IN EACH 4X4 TENT and just bought 2 GROW LIGHT SCIENCE GROW 300 on black Friday sale to replace the last 600 watt in 4x4 and have 1 MF 2000 in each of my 2 x4 propagation tents ,, do you have a mid price range LED recommendation to replace the 1000 watt HPS in the two five by five flower tents
Comment from : Darcy Potter Potter

I'm in the Desert 🏜️ brIs very 🥵 hot in the summer no in brside growing avreg is 95° up to 100°brGood video 📹👍
Comment from : Jason Lopez

I'v whent to HPS grow 🪴👍😤brGetting the best 🪴 ever 😜
Comment from : Jason Lopez

Shane is super smart I love how he always looks thirsty and baked Love this guy 🙌
Comment from : Oscar Silva

I never knew it matters from veg to flower changed the bulbs thanks
Comment from : Cali cartel

How come nobody does a PPFD reading with a grid pattern with the HID? its all about the parabolic arc and using crosslight!?
Comment from : TRD Pro Disobey

Percentages are always confusing to me as I'm not sure they are about energy flux or photon flux although they can be almost the same numbers in many cases but they are not the same things and can be different numbers depending on spectrum
Comment from : Mim Nun

@MIGRO hey i was wondering if using the cmh with a actual 315w ballast would give it better efficiency ??? Or you think it would still be some what similar? ALSO ANY INFO ON double ended cmh seems like they came out few years back but didn’t get very popular? Would really really appreciate any help thank you for your videos!! Honestly if I could afford it I’d get lights of your site just to support migro (and obviously they seem to be great lights as well just out of my budget for now)
Comment from : ROOKIExREVIEWS

Growing autos I think I would benefit from using hps the entire grow to get some structural stretch
Comment from : Tater Tot

you break it down so well thanks i am running an sp2000 in a 3x3 tent and i have to say i am impressed full spectrum heavy in reds peace
Comment from : david quintana

Would you elaborate on the humidity issue people will face while using solely LED lights ?
Comment from : Andrius Kazlauskas

Can you talk about btu's/ heat output? Do all the 600 watt class leds essentially put out the same amount of heat dictated by watts consumed? Compare the heat from a 600 class led to a 600 watt hps same heat? 630 watt cmh same as well?
Comment from : Ryan

Thanks for your wisdom & knowledge professor much appreciated
Comment from : Brian Hawkins

I just love how lit this guy always looks giving us grow light recommendations good shit
Comment from : Spicy

You can run the maxibright 600w CMH with the old magnetic ballast
Comment from : Blair Wilson

Hi my friend Very nice and interesting chanel I buy a lec lamp "Solux Parxtrem 600w 3100k" and my sorprise is that when i checked with par meter is a lot of less PPFD than the HPS Same distance, same place, same ballast, same moment, just changing the lamps I put the PAR meter "LightScout quantum par meter" and the HPS give me 1000ppfd and the lec lamp Solux Parxtrem 600w give me 580ppfd Is that normal???? I understant that is not normal, thats looks like this lec lamp solux parxtrem have the half efficienci umol/watt than the HPSbrbrThanks a lot my friend!!!
Comment from : ivan garcia

👏👏👏👏👏🏆🇪🇦🇪🇦🇪🇦🇪🇦
Comment from : Jose Antonio Liñan

Thanks alot for this video! I will be upgrading to ceramic
Comment from : Drake Butt

I dare you to compare t5
Comment from : Allen Norman

Great stuff! Love how you break down not only the spectrum, but also efficiency and cost of use LEDs are the obvious choice so glad I went that waymy 1st grow n my plants are exploding!
Comment from : Glockasaurus Wrex

Does maxi brite make a 1000 watt bulb ?
Comment from : The Nubby Nomad

Check out the Up DayDay UD4000 LED light , it uses CMH on LED lights!
Comment from : ItalianWiseGuy

i want to try out one of those DE big 1000watters i still have the old 1000watters things gotts be 20yrs old still running strong
Comment from : Mike C

I have 16 lights in my flower room 8 are quantom boards and 8 are cmh I get great results by staggering them
Comment from : A Mezera

According to this chart there's no advantage over 3 years to buying an LED You produce 70 of the light for 70 of the 3 year cost of an HPS
Comment from : Richard Petron

Great videos, I use led lights
Comment from : Mr Sours 420 growing adventures

The ease and flow of your side by side comparison chart deserves a Nobel prize
Comment from : aaron underwood

What if I add blue led on one side and red led on the other side of my hps light
Comment from : Compa Jesse

Your paying to much
Comment from : Robert Threm

Can you put a light cage under each one of those just slide it across the table I had to take my tomatoes out of the LED and put it in the sunlight Through the Windows and it still buried the gauge with the sunlight
Comment from : Robert Threm

If it says it's a 600-watt I don't think that means thats what you're using that's only the bulb what about the Transformer I'm not sure
Comment from : Robert Threm

Ive used high end led Sk600 400 and 600 watt MH and HPS 315 and 400 watt CMH and none are as good as the CMH bulbs The 400s have no problem doing 4X4 and run cooler than MH and HPS over the last 3 years
Comment from : jeffrey wolf

You should start your videos with you howling like a wolf
Comment from : Scragglewaggle

oasis know so much about growing
Comment from : Faze_washington6

I’m curious if there is a difference between a digital CMH ballast and a magnetic CMH ballast? I would suggest the digital ballast is more efficient?
Comment from : Eugenia Hobbs

lol, this guy is baked
Comment from : Lari Jauhiainen

You waste a lot of time
Comment from : 7777 Entschuldigungen

Thank you for your work!
Comment from : Jason Longo

"the bible" :)
Comment from : MRKWA

What we’ve all been wanting to know 👍
Comment from : ComptonChuckZ

2 thingsbr#1the use of cool tubes will greatly increase the size of your growing areabr#2graphs are great, but i need to see actual crop growth (start to finish) to make an actual comparison/decision
Comment from : au69miner

The real MVP of this video is that insanely level table
Comment from : Crafty

Thanks
Comment from : rlbball5

but you cant use the ceramic hps with a digi balast? only old magnetic? does it get hotter? My old magnetic balasts sure do make the bulbs hotter!
Comment from : Stuart

HPS the best!
Comment from : Lovasi András

The spectrum of the sun changes with the seasons The overhead summer sun shines more whitish-yellow and the Autumn sun coming in at such an angle has to cut through a much thicker layer of atmosphere, making it appear more reddish-orange But there is not a set spectrum for the sun in every season (from planet Earth's perspective) So you can not say "The sun's spectrum on the left" without accounting for seasons The same reason sunsets/rises are red-orange
Comment from : Saint Michael

This i cool ive used an 250w hps in a cooltube before in a secret jardin lodge with their 5000k double 55w t5 panel perfekt little system small atleast but went to hot during summer so i built a cfl panel instead for flower chamber it worked fine at the end and gave some fine yields with hydro Still im deadly curious on LED ramps ! your aray system is something im lookin at the smaller ones 270w i think for growing tomatoes and jalapenos and potatobuckets perhaps il need an larger one ? Im hoping that il find a tomato grow with your arraypanel to look at in before hand Good work Shane ! / Paul Roger north sweden
Comment from : Paul Roger Nilsson

I just need to clarify this, if you would mind helpingbrIs it a Lumatek ballast that is digital that you run the CMH HPS off of ? brbrThere is this website that sells CMH HPS maxibright 600 Watt, but in the very end it says "Do not use these lamps with digital ballasts - only magnetic"brbrIs this true ? brbrOr is it useable for a more advanced HPS ballast that is digital, GIB Lighting LXG 600w with integrated timer and remote brbrIt would be a shame if not
Comment from : Benjamin Nielsen

LEDS were the future and CMH was the reality "BUT Leds dont heat up" If I didnt need heat I would be growing outdoors! brbrI´ve seen setups with leds and heaters So sad
Comment from : Salo Vila

So you need ceramic mh for veg and ceramic hps for flowering ???brDidn't know ceramic hps
Comment from : gul:stan

I am growing 4 plants on my channel with 2 mars hydro 600 in a 3x3 and so far I am very happy and electricity bill is very reasonable
Comment from : Dustin

Hi love your vids and have subbed My friend was wanting to know the best hang height for a 400w hps during veg?
Comment from : Lemmy Richards

Bro you are stoned😂😂😂
Comment from : Foley

Do watt for watt not comparative wattage
Comment from : JaJa’s Mid Grade

Root Box Hydroponics uses the newest innovations in RDWC technology with the best parts We have many different 2, 3 and 4 Row RDWC Systems, accommodating many grow size spaces Fast plain box shipping Systems can be found on Ebay Amazon & Etsy Lets grow together!
Comment from : Root Box Hydroponics

I asked a question about this on another video of yours you answered my question in this video with the flowering I no it needs between 500-700nm yellow/red but what would u recommend knowing the spectacle range I would flower 500 - 650 max if I used led as 700 on wards seem abit close to inferred what's ur thoughts
Comment from : rhysyb

love your content man
Comment from : Jacob Hawk

Did they expect us to treat them with any respect

i grow watermelons and butternut squash in my basement what is this FLIP to flower??? lol
Comment from : Did they expect us to treat them with any respect

you put a 1000 watt 145,000 lumen EYE Hortilux super HPS in a 5x5 tent it better be a tall tent because with a parabolic shade and the bulb in the vertical position you will get well over 1000 ppfd average with the light 30 inches above the canopybrany old school magnetic ballast will ignite the ceramic HPS that Hortilux makes and wow is it red
Comment from : Torrie Landsman

I know you're busy but if you get a chance to get back to me is there a way to tell which bulbs are pd and are not worth keeping as you know we accumulate a few by!he but can waste a lot of time if they're useless
Comment from : pfitzsimmons008

Just a quick question I have 6oow 400v digital ballasts will ceramic hps bulbs work in those ballasts I was unaware when I bought them you had different bulbs to go in them thanks for keeping everyone updated on these lighting systems everyone seems to want to pay out for the very expensive led lights when there isn't much difference in the bps
Comment from : pfitzsimmons008

Thank you much! Love the information brought through your research
Comment from : Mr Binks

I use hps all the way
Comment from : Choppa 95

I’m past incandescent lightingim now running maxibright pro 660wthe rolls Royce of lighting
Comment from : marcosteffano

Great video Hoodie looks clean 🤙
Comment from : Chris Clyde

'Stretch' is not a bad thing when utilizing HPS bulbs I depend on internodal 'stretch' to open the plant canopy so the light can more easily hit the objective bud sites 'Stretch' increases maturation and yield by opening the canopy Versus tighter internodal spacing impedes light penetration into the plant canopy which dramatically reduces maturation and yield
Comment from : Gerald West